{Book Review} The sad case of a HUGELY anticipated book that disappoints.

isla and the happily ever afterBefore I start my review for Isla and the Happily Ever After, I have to say that I still love, love, love Stephanie Perkins! Her first book, Anna and the French Kiss, is one that I could read over and over again, and don’t get me started on her book boys — Etienne and Cricket are some of the BEST book boys!

If you read Isla and loved it, you might want to skip over this review because it’s definitely not in praise of the story — even though I wanted it to be.

I had been looking forward to Isla and the Happily Ever After for a long, long time. I think that’s something that led to my disappointment as I was reading. When I read about Anna and Lola, I laughed, I cried, and I fell in love with them. There was something about Isla that was just so off for me. She didn’t seem to have any ambition, whereas Anna and Lola were full of it, and she just seemed so … down … for the majority of the story.

Then there’s Josh, who is supposed to be a swoonworthy character, but I kind of saw him as an actor, who could put on a show for whoever he was trying to impress. He didn’t have that same charm that Etienne and Cricket had, he didn’t have that same unique personality that they each had.

Was I comparing too much while reading this story? Probably, but I couldn’t help it. Stephanie Perkins’s first two books are ones that I could continuously read and read and read and when I finished this one, I just didn’t feel the same way. I didn’t want to revisit Isla’s world again because honestly? It just depressed me.

Even if I didn’t enjoy the characters, I would’ve loved to say that the story redeemed itself, but it just lacked the focus that the first two books had. The whole book was just about two people — two sexually charged teens — who just want to get together to get it on, basically. I thought it was a story that dragged on, mainly because everything happens right at the start. Isla loves Josh for her entire life and then they get together. There was just no build up that made me want these two people to get together because once I got to know them, I just didn’t like them at all.

There was also a lack of humour in the story. Again with the comparisons, but I found myself laughing out loud so much while reading about Anna or Lola. They were both so quirky and funny that they made me want to just keep reading. But Isla? There was not a lot of humour, at least nothing to make me bust a gut, and she was just kind of a ‘meh’ character the whole time.

And lastly, there’s the scenery. We’re back in Paris! We go to Barcelona! But instead of feeling like I was right there with the characters in the story, it was just a bunch of name dropping of locations. The atmosphere was just lost on me.

I’m sad to say, but this was just such a disappointment for me. I wanted to love it. I wanted to swoon. I wanted to fall in love. And in the end, I feel like it was the pretty colours of the cover that I loved the most and that was it. I know I had read somewhere that when Stephanie Perkins wrote the first two books in this series, she wrote it during the pressure of NaNoWriMo. Maybe the fun of writing those stories in such a short amount of time is what led to their charm? Maybe she mulled over this one for too long of a time? I guess we’ll see what the next book holds.

Have you read this book? Have you ever highly anticipated a story and been disappointed? 



10 thoughts on “{Book Review} The sad case of a HUGELY anticipated book that disappoints.

  1. I haven’t read this one yet, but my anticipation has been tempered with some wariness. I loved Perkins’s previous two books, but from what I saw of Josh and Isla in Anna in the French Kiss, I wasn’t particularly interested in them as characters. So I’m not sure how I’m going to feel about an entire book devoted to them, particularly if there’s as little character development as you suggest.

    • Yeah, revisiting Anna right now, Josh isn’t that great of a character … I think I’d rather a book with Meredith or something than Isla and Josh, BUT I read it. It’s done. Now I can only hope the next one will be better!

    • It makes me think of the Hundred Oaks book by Miranda Kenneally that was really religion-heavy. It’s still definitely part of the series, but such a different tone. I’m curious how the next book in this series will be.

  2. I’ve been super excited about this book and I should be reading it within the next few days so maybe I will go into it a little more guarded now. Sorry you didn’t love it as much as the other two! I honestly read Anna SO long ago that I don’t even remember who Isla and Josh are… which might be a first sign right there? Guess I’ll see!

  3. I definitely felt the same way after reading Isla! I wondered if re-reading Anna and Lola beforehand might have made me feel differently, but honestly, I might have liked it even less.

    I felt like the personalities weren’t there for either character, but Isla especially. I read an interview SP did for Hello Giggles where she said Isla wasn’t given an interest because Josh’s was big enough for both of them. For what is generally a sex-positive series about girls chasing their dreams, I just couldn’t believe that. It made me feel even more negatively about the book.

My home is where my books are. - Ellen Thompson

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s